Skip to content
BrowseCf Star Removal
Descriptive only — a measured pattern, no edge claimed.
Analytics module · as of 2024-25 (Elo end-of-season) x 2024_25 on/off slice

Star Removal: what one player is worth in win-prob points

Take Nikola Jokic off Denver and, on a neutral floor against a league-average team, the Nuggets' win probability falls from 0.634 to 0.0517 -- a 0.5822 swing, the largest of any team's top on/off player.
View full size ↗
confirmednull (a finding)not testabledescriptivepending
Cf Star Removal
Chart: Cf Star Removal -- Take Nikola Jokic off Denver and, on a neutral floor against a league-average team, the Nuggets' win probability falls from 0.634 to 0.0517 -- a 0.5822 swing, the largest of any team's top on/off player.
scripts/platformkit/analytics_showcase/out/cf_star_removal.json2024-25 (Elo end-of-season) x 2024_25 on/off slice

What it means

Each team's biggest on/off swing player is mapped onto the Elo win-prob curve to ask a blunt what-if: how much of this roster's strength walks out the door with that one name. Jokic's swing is enormous because Denver's on-court net rating collapses without him and the logistic curve turns that into a near-total win-prob wipeout. The numbers are a ceiling, not a clean causal player value -- a full-lineup on-vs-off gap gets attributed to one man.

Caveats & confounds

CEILING: the on/off net-rating delta overstates marginal individual value -- it is a full-lineup swing with no control for teammates, opponent, coach trust, or garbage time (roster confound), and the net-rating-to-Elo conversion is a single frozen constant, not a fit. DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY, not a causal or edge claim.

Method.

rating to prob curve
repo Elo logistic 1/(1+10^(-d/400))
star rating removed
on_off_net_rating_delta * ELO_PER_NETRATING_POINT
elo per netrating point
25.3333
elo per netrating point anchor
elo_config.ELO_HFA=76 Elo ~ 3.0-pt home edge (76/3.0)
reference opponent elo
1500
site
neutral
weights tuned to output
false
Ask Scout about this
How much is Jokic worth to Denver in win probability?How does OKC's win probability change with and without SGA?Why is the biggest on/off player on some teams a role player and not the star?Ask anything →